Appl. Math. Mech. -Engl. Ed.   2017, Vol. 38 Issue (8): 1071-1090     PDF       
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10483-017-2223-9
Shanghai University
0

Article Information

Dan WANG, Yajun YIN, Jiye WU, Zheng ZHONG
Duality in interaction potentials for curved surface bodies and inside particles
Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 2017, 38(8): 1071-1090.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10483-017-2223-9

Article History

Received Nov. 1, 2016
Revised Dec. 6, 2016
Duality in interaction potentials for curved surface bodies and inside particles
Dan WANG1 , Yajun YIN1 , Jiye WU2 , Zheng ZHONG3     
1. Department of Engineering Mechanics, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China;
2. Department of Civil Engineering, Nanjing Tech University, Nanjing 211800, China;
3. Department of Engineering Mechanics, Tongji University, Shanghai 200092, China
Abstract: Based on the viewpoint of duality, this paper studies the interaction between a curved surface body and an inside particle. By convex/concave bodies with geometric duality, interaction potentials of particles located outside and inside the curved surface bodies are shown to have duality. With duality, the curvature-based potential between a curved surface body and an inside particle is derived. Furthermore, the normal and tangential driving forces exerted on the particle are studied and expressed as a function of curvatures and curvature gradients. Numerical experiments are designed to test accuracy of the curvature-based potential.
Key words: micro/nano curved surface body     duality     curvature-based potential     curvature     curvature gradient     driving force    
1 Introduction

At micro/nano scales, highly curved structures widely exist, and the importance of curved space form is gradually realized.Previously, we discussed the interaction between curved spaces(i.e., curved surface and curved line) and particles[1-4]. Then, the interaction between curved surface bodies and particles was explored[5-6]. As a three-dimensional body, the curved surface body belongs to the flat Euclid space. However, at small scales, the surface of the body is highly curved, and most of the particles are distributed on the surface with large specific surface area. From this viewpoint, the highly curved surface body is closely related to the curved space[5].

In the previous paper[6], the interaction between a curved surface body and a particle was classified into three basic modes.The first one is the interaction between a curved surface body and a particle located outside the body (see Fig. 1(a)), which is marked as Mode 1. The second one is the interaction between a curved surface body and a particle located on the surface of the body (see Fig. 1(b)) and is marked as Mode 2. The third one is the interaction between a curved surface body and a particle located inside the body (see Fig. 1(c)), which is called Mode 3. Modes 1and 2 have been well studied[6-7]. Based on the negative exponential pair potential ((1/R)n), interaction potentials in Modes 1 and 2 have been expressed as functions of curvatures through differential geometry.

Fig. 1 Three basic interaction modes between curved surface body and particle

In this paper, Mode 3, i.e., the interaction between a curved surface body and an inside particle, is studied.

A lot of mechanical phenomena can be abstracted as Mode 3. For example, in the coffee ring effect[8], the interaction between coffee granules and water drop drives ordered motion and forms ordered pattern[9]. In hydrogen embrittlement[10], hydrogen atoms diffuse and accumulate in internal defect to cause cracking of metal. In a biological system, particles may move along the biomembrane nanotube[11].

Based on the physical/mathematical model of Mode 3, this paper aims to express the interaction potential of a curved surface body and an inside particle as a function of curvatures, with which the abnormal movements of particles at small scales may be explained from the viewpoint of geometry.

2 Research approaches to Mode 3

To study Mode 3, two research approaches may be selected. One is the direct approach, and the other is the indirect approach.

The direct approach is to derive the curvature-based potential for Mode 3 directly. This approach is complex and similar to that in Modes 1 and 2. For this reason, this paper puts the direct approach in Appendix A for reference.

Based on duality, the curvature-based potential of Mode 1 may be transformed into the curvature-based potential of Mode 3, which forms the indirect approach. In fact, Modes 1 and 3 have a close relation depicted as duality. Here, duality corresponds to a kind of additive algebraic operation. Thus, we can establish simple relations between the curvature-based potential of Modes 1 and 3.

3 Dual material space and dual interaction potential

Duality is the thought that has important applications in modern science. Examples include the Poincare duality theorem in the manifold[12] and the Desargues theorem in the projective geometry[13].

Duality here means the complementary of material space. In Fig. 2, there is a three-dimensional infinite body V and a particle p with an equivalent radius τ inside the body. Suppose that the particle p interacts with other particles in V, and the pair-potential is u. The number density of particles in V is ρ. Then, the interaction potential between the particle p and other particles in V is

Fig. 2 Interaction between infinite body and inside particle
(1)

Now, we use an imaginary curved surface S to cut the infinite body V (see Fig. 3). Suppose that the nearest distance between the particle p and the surface S is h, i.e.,

Fig. 3 Infinite body cut by plane
(2)

As shown in Fig. 4, the infinite body V is segmented by the imaginary curved surface S into two parts, i.e., the convex body and the concave body are geometrically complementary. According to the position of particle p, two cases may be abstracted. One is that the particle p locates inside the convex body (i.e., ) and outside the concave body (i.e., ) (see Fig. 4). The other is that the particle p locates outside the convex body (i.e., ) and inside the concave body (i.e., ) (see Fig. 5). Both cases obey the complementary invariability as follows:

Fig. 4 Infinite body cut by curved surface with particle located at concave side of curved surface
Fig. 5 Infinite body cut by curved surface with particle located at convex side of curved surface
(3)
(4)

Correspondingly, the interaction potentials in two cases satisfy the following duality invariability:

(5)
(6)

Here,

(7)
(8)

The duality shown in Eqs.(5) and (6) brings great convenience for later study. As the interaction potentials outer and outer have been studied in Mode 1, the interaction potentials inner and inner in Mode 3 can be derived from the dual relations in Eqs.(5) and (6).

As shown in Fig. 3, if the surface S is a plane, Eqs.(5) and(6) will degenerate to

(9)

Here, Uouter and Uinner represent the interaction potential between the planar surface body (or semi-infinite body)and an outside particle or an inside particle, respectively.

Similar to the previous paper[5-7], the pair-potential u is taken as the form of negative exponential[15],

(10)
4 Interaction potential between semi-infinite body and inside particle

As shown in Fig. 2, based on the negative exponential pair potential in Eq.(1), the interaction potential between the infinite body V and the inside particle p is

(11)

It is noted that there is only one characteristic size in Eq.(11), i.e., the particle equivalent radius τ. For the given material, τ is a constant.

From the previous paper[6], the interaction potential between the semi-infinite body Vouter and the outside particle p is

(12)

There is also one characteristic size in Eq.(12), i.e., the distance h.

By duality in Eq.(9), we get

(13)

In Eq.(13), there are two characteristic sizes, i.e., the particle equivalent radius τ and the distance h. Equation(13) can be further written as

(14)

where is the dimensionless interaction potential between the semi-infinite body Vinner and the inside particle p. is the ratio of two characteristic sizes,

is a dimensionless parameter of characteristic scale. Generally speaking, there is τ ≤ h or ≤ 1.

5 Interaction potential between convex curved surface body and inside particle

Firstly, Mode 3 for the convex body inner is studied. As shown in Fig. 6, when the particle p locates inside a convex body inner, it must be outside the dual concave body outer at the same time (Mode 1 for outer, see Fig. 7). Mode 3 for inner and Mode 1 for outer are dual.

To ensure uniformity, a unified coordinate system is used. As shown in Figs. 6 and 7, a local Cartesian coordinate system O-xyz is built at the nearest point O on the surfaceS. The x-and y-axes coincide with the tangent direction of the principle curvature lines at the point O on S. The z-axis always points to the concave side of the surface S. The distance between the point O and the particle p is h. By duality, the interaction potential for Mode 3 in Fig. 6 can be derived under such a uniform coordinate.

Fig. 6 Interaction between convex body and inside particle under principle curvature coordinate system
Fig. 7 Interaction between dual concave body and outside particle under principle curvature coordinate system

Under the coordinate system shown in Fig. 7, the curvature-based potential between the concave body outer and the outside particle (Mode 1 for outer) is[6]

(16)

Here,

(17)

in which c1 and c2 are the principle curvatures, H and are the mean curvature and the dimensionless mean curvature, respectively, and K and are the Gauss curvature and the dimensionless Gauss curvature, respectively. If →0, →0, then there is outerUouter, i.e., the interaction potential between a concave body and an outside particle degenerates to that between a semi-infinite body and an outside particle.

Substituting Eq.(16) into the dual relation (see Eq.(5)), we get

(18)

Equation(18) can be written as follows:

(19)

If →0, and →0, then Eq.(19) turns to

(20)

The interaction potential between a convex body and an inside particle degenerates to that between a semi-infinite body and an inside particle.

6 Curvature-based potential between concave body and inside particle

Now, we consider the case in which the particle p locates inside the concave body inner (i.e., Mode 3 for inner, see Fig. 8). In this case, the particlep must be outside the dual convex body outer at the same time (i.e., Mode 1 for outer, see Fig. 9).

Fig. 8 Interaction between concave body and inside particle under principle curvature coordinate system
Fig. 9 Interaction between convex body and outside particle under principle curvature coordinate system

The same uniform coordinate system as Figs. 6 and 7 is built (see Figs. 8 and 9). In the coordinate system in Fig. 9, the curvature-based interaction potential for Mode 1[6] is known as

(21)

When →0, and →0, there is outerUouter, i.e., the interaction potential between a convex body and an outside particle degenerates to that between a semi-infinite body and an outside particle.

Substitution of Eq.(21) into the dual relation in Eq.(6) leads to

(22)

Equation (22) can be further written as

(23)

When there is

The interaction potential between a concave body and an inside particle degenerates to that between a semi-infinite body and an inside particle.

7 Unified formulation of curvature-based potentials between convex/conc-ave body and inside particle

Equation (23) reveals that if the surface is highly curved, the effect of curvatures cannot be ignored. Thus, the movements of particles inside the curved surface body are strongly controlled by the morphology of the surface of the curved surface body.

By comparing Eq.(2) with Eq.(23), we find that the curvature-based potentials between a convex/concave body and an inside particle have small difference, that is, the sign of the term is different. Thus, in the above unified coordinate system, Eqs.(2) and (23) can be written in the unified form as follows:

(24)
8 Curvature-based driving force exerted on inside particle

Once the potential mode 3 is confirmed, the driving forces acting on the particle p can be determined. There are also two approaches to study the driving forces acting on the particle p. One is the direct approach, in which the driving forces exerted on the particle p are derived from Eq.(24) directly. The other is the indirect approach, in which the driving forces are studied by the dual relation.

This section will introduce the indirect approach and derive driving forces quantitatively by the direct approach.

8.1 Indirect approach: from dual interaction potentials to dual driving forces

The indirect approach originates from the dual relations in Eqs.(5) and (6), which can be written in a unified form of

(25)

Taking the gradient on both sides of Eq.(25) leads to

(26)

Here, ∇ is the gradient operator defined in the three-dimensional space,

(27)

where i, j, and k are base vectors in the rectangular coordinate system. The relations between the potentials and driving forces are

(28)

As is a constant, there is

(29)

Equations(26), (27), and (28) may give the dual driving forces,

(30)

Proposition may be drawn from Eq.(3). For convex and concave bodies with geometric duality, their driving forces on the particle may form an equilibrium force system.

The equilibrium relation between can be depicted in Fig. 10. Equation(30) leads to In the previous paper[6], the driving force has been written as the function of curvatures. Thus, the curvature-based driving force acting on the particle by the dual curved surface body can be derived from Eq.(31).

Fig. 10 Equilibrium relation between outer and inner and equilibrium relation between outer and inner
(31)

From the derivation process above, a general proposition can be deduced. The curvature-based driving force acting on the particle located inside the curved surface body is independent of the equivalent radiusτ of the particle.

In Eq.(11), the equivalent radius τ of the particle p only appears in the potential . Because is a constant and ∇ is a zero vector, the equivalent radius τ only affects the interaction potentials, and does not affect the driving forces.

8.2 Direct approach: from curvature-based potential to curvature-based driving force

For convenience, all the terms in the bracket of Eq.(23) are written as a dimensional form,

(32)
8.2.1 Normal driving force acting on inside particle

Suppose that the particle p is confined to move in the normal direction z. In the coordinate system in Fig. 6, the driving force in the z-direction felt by the particle p inside the convex body is

(33)

When H=0, and K=0, Eq.(33) degenerates to the normal driving force of the particle located inside the semi-infinite body,

(34)

In Fig. 8, the normal driving force acting on the particle pinside the concave body is

(35)

Equation (35) shows that the driving force is indeed independent of the equivalent radius τ. The normal driving force Fz is strongly regulated by the curvatures of the surface of the curved surface body. This result confirms the previous proposition[6].A curved space may induce driving forces.

8.2.2 Tangential driving force acting on inside particle

A surface with constant distance to the curved surface body, i.e., h=const., is called a parallel curved surface. Suppose that the particle is confined to move on a parallel curved surface. It will feel a tangential force in the tangent plane of the parallel curved surface (see Fig. 11),

Fig. 11 Curvature-based tangential driving force acting on particle inside curved surface body
(36)

In Eq.(36), is the gradient operator defined in the parallel curved surface,

Here, gi are the natural base vectors, and ui are the Gauss parameter coordinate in the parallel curved surface. Substituting Eq.(23) into Eq.(36) yields

(37)

Equation (37) shows that is also independent of the equivalent radius τ of the particle. Equation (37) indicates that not only the curvatures but also the gradients of curvatures are the fundamental elements in the tangential driving forces.

If H=0, and K=0, there is Ft=0, i.e., no tangential force is acting on the particle inside the semi-infinite body.

For a cylinder and sphere, as the gradients of curvatures are zero, the tangential driving forces acting on the inside particles are also zero.

9 Numerical verification of curvature-based potential between curved surface body and inside particle

This section verifies the accuracy of the curvature-based potential inner. According to Eqs.(5) and (6), the accuracy of inner is directly determined by the accuracy of curvature-based potential outer. In the previous paper[6], the accuracy of outer has been verified. From the duality in Eqs.(5) and (6), it can be deduced that the accuracy of inner is assured. Thus, this paper does not verify the effect of curvatures on inner, but focuses on the effect of the dimensionless equivalent radius =τ/ h on the accuracy of inner, which is listed in Tables 1 and 2.

Table 1 Accuracy of curvature-based potential of convex body and inside particle (n=6, , and
Table 2 Accuracy of curvature-based potential of concave body and inside particle (n=6, and

Firstly, the curvature-based potential (see Eq.(23)) is rewritten as

(38)

Equation (38) is changed to

(39)

Both sides of Eq.(39) are divided by Uinner to get the dimensionless curvature-based potential,

(40)

Secondly, both sides of Eq.(A20) in Appendix A are divided by Uinner to get the integral form of dimensionless potential,

(41)

Here, is the dimensionless coordinate of the particle. The specific definition can be found in Eq.(A16). is the dimensionless normal curvature at the point O,

(42)

Finally, are compared, and the accuracy may be estimated,

(43)

From Tables 1 and 2, we find the tendency below. The smaller the parameter is (i.e., the bigger the distance h is), the higher accuracy the curvature-based potential has. This can be easily understood from the physical diagram. The farther the particle is away from the curved surface body, the smaller the effect of the curvature is, and the higher the accuracy of the curvature-based potential is. Overall, the accuracy of curvature-based potential is very high when ranges in a broad region.

10 Potential energy gap between three basic modes

Together with the previous works[5-7], the interaction potentials of Modes 1, 2, and 3 are all expressed as functions of curvatures marked as Uouter, Uon, and Uinner, as shown in Fig. 12.Now, we consider the potential gap between the three modes. The pair potential between the particles is written as Un=C/R, in which a positive C means repulsive potential, while a negative Crepresents the attractive potential. Uouter, Uon, and Uinner are written as

Fig. 12 Interaction between particle and curved surface body
(44a)
(44b)
(44c)

There is λ=1 for the convex body and λ=-1 for the concave body. For attractive interaction, there is Uinner < Uon < Uouter, and the particle p tends to stay inside the body under the action of the normal driving force Fz (see Fig. 13(a)). For repulsive interaction, there is Uouter < Uon < Uinner, and the particle p prefers to stay away from the body under the influence of the normal driving force Fz(see Fig. 13(b)).

Fig. 13 Movements of particle under action of normal driving force

When H→0, and K→0, the curved surface body changes to a semi-infinite plane body, as shown in Fig. 14. Now, the interaction potentials between the particles under three models are

Fig. 14 Interaction between particle and semi-infinite plane body
(45a)
(45b)
(45c)

The interaction potential gap between three modes of particle and semi-infinite plane body is

(46)

Equation (46) indicates that when the curved surface body is fat enough, the potential gap between Modes 1 and 2 is equal to that between Modes 2 and 3.

As shown in Fig. 12, when the surface bends, the potential gap between three models is

(47a)
(47b)
(47c)

As the curvature based potential is derived based on the assumption that Hh and Kh2 are small quantities, the term in Eq.(47) is a small quantity with high order and can be omitted in the following discussion. As n>4 and hτ, there is

(48)

Equation (47) indicates that the potential gaps between three modes are closely related to the surface morphology, i.e., the mean curvature H. By combining Eqs.(47) and (48), we get the judgment below. For the convex body, ∆Uinner-on increases but ∆Uon-outer decreases along with the increase of the mean curvature H, while for the concave body, ∆Uinner-on decreases and ∆Uon-outer increases along with the increase of the mean curvature H.

11 Conclusions

On the basis of duality, this paper derives the curvature-based interaction potential between a curved surface body and an inside particle. From the dual geometric structures to the dual interaction potentials and driving forces, we can find that duality plays an important role. This paper confirms the proposition. The interaction potential between a curved surface body and an inside particle can be expressed as a function of surface curvatures. Besides, a highly curved surface body can induce driving forces on the inside particle, and the curvatures and the gradient of curvatures are the fundamental elements of the driving forces.

Appendix A

Similar to the approach used in the previous paper[6], the curvature-based potential is deduced as follows.

A1 Approximation of local shape of curved surface body

Similar to the previous paper[6], the local shape of the curved surface body V needs to be approximated to derive the curvature-based potential. As the particle p mainly interacts with the adjacent area around the point O, which is the nearest point on the curved surface body to the particle p, the local shape of curved surface body around the point O should be approximated as accurate as possible. This is a classical problem in differential geometry[16]. Under the principal coordinate system O-xyz at the point O, the surface S of the curved surface body V can be approximated by the surface S with the analytic expression below,

(A1)

Here, c1 and c2 are the principal curvatures of curved surface S the point O. The curved surface body with the surfaceS is marked as V0. The original curved surface body V is approximated by V0, and the potential between V and the particle p is substituted by the potential between V0 and the particle p. The local relation between V0 and V is shown in Fig. A1.

Fig. A1 Relation between original curved surface body V and approximate curved surface bodyV0
A2 General formulation of interaction potential

As shown in Figs. A2 and A3, a spherical surface Sp is drawn with its center at the particle p and the radius R to intersect with V0. Suppose that the area of the intersection surface between Sp and V0 is A. Then, the interaction potential between V0 and the particle p is

Fig. A2 Interaction between convex curved surface body and inside particle
Fig. A3 Interaction between concave curved surface body and inside particle
(A2)

Equation(A2) is valid for both convex V0 and concave V0.

A3 Unified formulation of intersection area A

In Figs. A2 and A3, when the radius R of sphere surface Sp is smaller than the nearest distance from the particle p to the curved surface S0, the intersection area is equal to the area of sphere surface Sp, i.e.,

(A3)

In the case of R>h, in order to derive the interaction area A, a cylindrical coordinate system p-rθ z with the particle p as the pole and the x-axis as the polar axis is established. The transformation between (x, y) and (r, θ) is

(A4)

By substituting Eq.(A4) into Eq.(A1), we have

(A5)

Here,

(A6)

kn is the normal curvature of S0 at the point O.

For a convex body (see Fig. A2), suppose that the point B is an arbitrary point on the intersection line between Sp and S0.Then, a vertical line is drawn from the point B to the z-axis and meets the z-axis at the point C. In the triangle ABP, there is

(A7)

Here, Rk =|CB|, and z is the coordinate of the point B in the z-axis. In the cylindrical coordinate system, there exists

(A8)

The intersection area of the sphere Sp and the convex body is

(A9)

By combining Eq.(A5) and Eq.(A7), we get the calculation formula for Rk,

(A10)

Substitution of Eq.(A10) into Eq.(A9) leads to

(A11)

For the concave body (see Fig. 12), in the triangle ABC, there is

(A12)

The intersection area is

(A13)

Combination of Eq.(A5) and Eq.(A12) may give the calculation formula for Rk,

(A14)

Substitution of Eq.(A14) into Eq.(A13) leads to

(A15)

To unify and , we define the coordinate of particle p as (0, 0, zp), and the dimensionless coordinate is defined as

(A16)

There is for concave V0. Obviously, by the dimensionless coordinate , Eqs.(A11) and (A15) can be unified as

(A17)

Substituting Eqs.(A17) and (A3) into Eq.(A2) to get the unified interaction potential between a convex/concave body V0 and an inside particle p,

(A18)
A4 Curvature-based interaction potential

In Eq.(A18), kn is the function of principal curvatures c1, c2, and θ. In this section, Eq.(A18) will be written as an explicit formula of two principal curvatures c1 and c2. It is noted that Eq.(A18) is very similar to the formulation in the previous paper[6]. Thus, this section will still use the series expansion of small parametric variable[17].

The shortest distance h between the particle p and S0 is used as the characteristic length to define the dimensionless variables,

(A19)

Then, Eq.(A18) can be rewritten as

(A20)

In Eq.(A20), let

(A21)

Here, is the continuous and differentiable function of . From Eqs.(A6) and (A19), we get

(A22)

Suppose that the distance h is a small quantity compared with the curvature radius at the point O on the curved surface body,

(A23)

From Eq.(A22), n is also a small quantity, i.e., can be taken as the small parametric variable, and the series expansion method may be used[17]. can be expanded into Taylor's series of small parametric variable ,

(A24)

For simplification, we omit the terms with orders

(A25)

Substitution of Eq.(A25) into Eq.(A20) gives

(A26)

In Eq.(A26),

(A27)
(A28)

Substituting Eq.(A27) and Eq.(A28) into Eq.(A26) leads to the interaction potential depicted by the principal curvatures,

(A29)

Equation(A29) can be rewritten as

(A30)

Equation(A30) is exactly the same as Eq.(27).

References
[1] Yin, Y. J., Chen, C., Lü, C. J., and Zheng, Q. S. Shape gradient and classical gradient of curvatures:driving forces on micro/nano curved surfaces. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 32(5), 533-550 (2011) doi:10.1007/s10483-011-1436-6
[2] Wu, J. Y., Yin, Y. J., Wang, X. G., and Fan, Q. S. Interaction potential between micro/nano curved surface and a particle located inside the surface (Ⅰ):driving forces induced by curvatures. Science China:Physics Mechanics and Astronomy, 55(6), 1066-1076 (2012) doi:10.1007/s11433-012-4738-1
[3] Wu, J. Y., Yin, Y. J., Huang, K., and Fan, Q. S. Interaction potential between micro/nano curved surface and a particle located inside the surface (Ⅱ):numerical experiment and equipotential surfaces. Science China:Physics Mechanics and Astronomy, 55(6), 1077-1082 (2012) doi:10.1007/s11433-012-4737-2
[4] Wang, X. G., Yin, Y. J., Wu, J. Y., and Wang, D. Curvature-based interaction potential between an isolated particle and micro/nano space curve. Physica E:Low-Dimensional Systems and Nanostructures, 67, 178-191 (2015) doi:10.1016/j.physe.2014.10.034
[5] Wang, D., Yin, Y. J., Wu, J. Y., and Zhong, Z. Interaction potential between parabolic rotator and an outside particle. Journal of Nanomaterials, 2014, 1-6 (2014)
[6] Wang, D., Yin, Y. J., Wu, J. Y., and Zhong, Z. Curvature-based interaction potential between micro/nano curved surface body and an outside particle. Journal of Computational and Theoretical Nanoscience, 12(12), 1-12 (2015)
[7] Wang, D., Yin, Y. J., Wu, J. Y., and Zhong, Z. Curvature-based interaction potential between micro/nano curved surface body and a particle on the surface of the body. Journal of Biological Physics, 42(1), 33-51 (2015)
[8] Peter, J. Y., Tim, S., Matthew, A. L., and Yodh, A. G. Suppression of the coffee-ring effect byshape-dependent capillary interactions. nature, 476(18), 308-311 (2011)
[9] Zhao, Y. P. Physical Mechanics of Surfaces and Interfaces, Science Press,, Beijing (2012)
[10] Johnson, H. H. Hydrogen embrittlement. Science, 179, 228-230 (1973)
[11] Rustom, A., Saffrich, R., and Markovic, I. Nanotubular highways for intercellular organelle transport. Science, 303, 1007-1010 (2004) doi:10.1126/science.1093133
[12] Blanchfield, R. C. Intersection theory of manifolds with operators with applications to knot theory. Annals of Mathematics, 65(2), 340-356 (1957) doi:10.2307/1969966
[13] Hilbert, D. and Cohn-Vossen, S. Geometry and the Imagination, 2nd ed., Chelsea, New York, 119-128(1952)
[14] Negrepontis, J. W. Duality in analysis from the point of view of triples. Journal of Algebra, 19(2), 228-253 (1971) doi:10.1016/0021-8693(71)90105-0
[15] Israelachvili, J. Intermolecular and Surface Forces, 3nd ed , Academic Press, London (2011)
[16] Su, B. Q., Hu, H. S., Shen, C. L., Pan, Y. L., and Zhang, G. L. Differential Geometry, People's Education Press, Beijing, 16-18 (1979)
[17] Wu, J. Y. Biomembrane Free Energy, the Driving Forces Induced by Curvature Gradients (in Chinese), Ph. D.. dissertation. Tsinghua University, 40-45 (2012)