Nonlinear metamaterial enabled aeroelastic vibration reduction of a supersonic cantilever wing plate

doi:10.1007/s10483-024-3165-7

Abstract

Abstract:

The violent vibration of supersonic wings threatens aircraft safety. This paper proposes the strongly nonlinear acoustic metamaterial (NAM) method to mitigate aeroelastic vibration in supersonic wing plates. We employ the cantilever plate to simulate the practical behavior of a wing. An aeroelastic vibration model of the NAM cantilever plate is established based on the mode superposition method and a modified third-order piston theory. The aerodynamic properties are systematically studied using both the time-domain integration and frequency-domain harmonic balance methods. While presenting the flutter and post-flutter behaviors of the NAM wing, we emphasize more on the pre-flutter broadband vibration that is prevalent in aircraft. The results show that the NAM method can reduce the low-frequency and broadband pre-flutter steady vibration by 50%-90%, while the post-flutter vibration is reduced by over 95%, and the critical flutter velocity is also slightly delayed. As clarified, the significant reduction arises from the bandgap, chaotic band, and nonlinear resonances of the NAM plate. The reduction effect is robust across a broad range of parameters, with optimal performance achieved with only 10% attached mass. This work offers a novel approach for reducing aeroelastic vibration in aircraft, and it expands the study of nonlinear acoustic/elastic metamaterials.

Key words: nonlinear acoustic metamaterial (NAM), hypersonic aeroelastic vibration, vibration reduction, fluid-structure interaction

2010 MSC Number:

74H45

Peng SHENG, Xin FANG, Dianlong YU, Jihong WEN. Nonlinear metamaterial enabled aeroelastic vibration reduction of a supersonic cantilever wing plate. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 2024, 45(10): 1749-1772.

TrendMD

Figures/Tables 17

Fig. 1

Fig. 2

Table 1

Fig. 3

Fig. 4

Fig. 5

Fig. 6

Fig. 7

Fig. 8

Fig. 9

Fig. 10

Fig. 11

Fig. 12

Fig. 13

Fig. 14

Fig. 15

Fig. 16

References 60

1	LI, H., WU, S., CHEN, Q., and FEI, Q. Design of dynamic absorbers to control the flexural resonant vibration of structures characterized by multiple natural modes. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 513, 116415 (2021)
2	LU, S. F., JIANG, Y., ZHANG, W., and SONG, X. J. Vibration suppression of cantilevered piezoelectric laminated composite rectangular plate subjected to aerodynamic force in hygrothermal environment. European Journal of Mechanics-A/Solids, 83, 104002 (2020)
3	CHAI, Y., GAO, W., ANKAY, B., LI, F., and ZHANG, C. Aeroelastic analysis and flutter control of wings and panels: a review. International Journal of Mechanical System Dynamics, 1 (1), 5- 34 (2021)
4	ZHU, Y., YAO, G., WANG, M., GAO, K., and HOU, Q. A new pre-stretching method to increase critical flutter dynamic pressure of heated panel in supersonic airflow. Mathematics, 10 (23), 4506 (2022)
5	JONSSON, E., RISO, C., LUPP, C. A., CESNIK, C. E. S., MARTINS, J. R. R. A., and EPUREANU, B. I. Flutter and post-flutter constraints in aircraft design optimization. Progress in Aerospace Sciences, 109, 100537 (2019)
6	FERNANDES, R. R., and TAMIJANI, A. Y. Flutter analysis of laminated curvilinear-stifiened plates. AIAA Journal, 55 (3), 998- 1011 (2017)
7	ZHAO, H., and CAO, D. A study on the aero-elastic flutter of stifiened laminated composite panel in the supersonic flow. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 332 (19), 4668- 4679 (2013)
8	KURUP, M., and PITCHAIMANI, J. Aeroelastic flutter of triply periodic minimal surface (TPMS) beams. Composites Part C: Open Access, 10, 100349 (2023)
9	KOU, J., and ZHANG, W. Data-driven modeling for unsteady aerodynamics and aeroelasticity. Progress in Aerospace Sciences, 125, 100725 (2021)
10	MOTE, C. D. Aerodynamically excited vibration and flutter of a thin disk rotating at supercritical speed. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 168 (1), 15- 30 (1993)
11	TONG, X. D., CHEN, H. Y., and CHEN, Y. Low frequency broadband noise radiated by highly skewed propeller ingesting inflow turbulence. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 490, 115709 (2021)
12	SONG, X., JIN, G., YE, T., and ZHONG, S. A formulation for turbulent-flow-induced vibration of elastic plates with general boundary conditions. International Journal of Mechanical Sciences, 205, 106602 (2021)
13	AJAJ, R. M., PARANCHEERIVILAKKATHIL, M. S., AMOOZGAR, M., FRISWELL, M. I., and CANTWELL, W. J. Recent developments in the aeroelasticity of morphing aircraft. Progress in Aerospace Sciences, 120, 100682 (2021)
14	LI, P., YANG, Z., and TIAN, W. Nonlinear aeroelastic analysis and active flutter control of functionally graded piezoelectric material plate. Thin-Walled Structures, 183, 110323 (2023)
15	XUE, Y., LI, J., LI, F., and SONG, Z. Flutter and thermal buckling properties and active control of functionally graded piezoelectric material plate in supersonic airflow. Acta Mechanica Solida Sinica, 33 (5), 692- 706 (2020)
16	DONNELL, K. O., SCHOBER, S., STOLK, M., MARZOCCA, P., BREUKER, R., ABDALLA, M., NICOLINI, E., and GÜRDAL, Z. Active aeroelastic control aspects of an aircraft wing by using synthetic jet actuators: modeling, simulations, experiments. Proceedings of SPIE, 6523 (1), 652309 (2007)
17	MOREIRA, J. A., MOLEIRO, F., ARAÚJO, A. L., and PAGANI, A. Analytical modeling of panel flutter and active control in supersonic variable stifiness composite laminates. Mechanics of Advanced Materials and Structures, 30 (5), 930- 944 (2023)
18	BERNELLI-ZAZZERA, F., MANTEGAZZA, P., MAZZONI, G., and RENDINA, M. Active flutter suppression using recurrent neural networks. Journal of Guidance, Control, and Dynamics, 23 (6), 1030- 1036 (2000)
19	REZAEE, M., JAHANGIRI, R., and SHABANI, R. Robust adaptive fuzzy sliding mode control of nonlinear uncertain MIMO fluttering FGP plate based on feedback linearization. Aerospace Science and Technology, 91, 391- 409 (2019)
20	SHIVASHANKAR, P., and GOPALAKRISHNAN, S. Review on the use of piezoelectric materials for active vibration, noise, and flow control. Smart Materials and Structures, 29 (5), 53001 (2020)
21	LIN, H., SHAO, C., and CAO, D. Nonlinear flutter and random response of composite panel embedded in shape memory alloy in thermal-aero-acoustic coupled fleld. Aerospace Science and Technology, 100, 105785 (2020)
22	TSUSHIMA, N., and SU, W. Flutter suppression for highly flexible wings using passive and active piezoelectric efiects. Aerospace Science and Technology, 65, 78- 89 (2017)
23	KASSEM, M., YANG, Z., GU, Y., WANG, W., and SAFWAT, E. Active dynamic vibration absorber for flutter suppression. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 469, 115110 (2020)
24	PEIKKHOSH, S. P., DARDEL, M., and GHASEMI, M. H. Enhancing bandwidth of metamaterial plate with linear and nonlinear passive absorbers. International Journal of Non-Linear Mechanics, 135, 103769 (2021)
25	CHEN, J., ZHANG, W., YAO, M., LIU, J., and SUN, M. Vibration reduction in truss core sandwich plate with internal nonlinear energy sink. Composite Structures, 193, 180- 188 (2018)
26	HUANG, X., and YANG, B. Towards novel energy shunt inspired vibration suppression techniques: principles, designs and applications. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 182, 109496 (2023)
27	VERSTRAELEN, E., HABIB, G., KERSCHEN, G., and DIMITRIADIS, G. Experimental passive flutter suppression using a linear tuned vibration absorber. AIAA Journal, 55 (5), 1707- 1722 (2017)
28	BAB, S., KHADEM, S. E., SHAHGHOLI, M., and ABBASI, A. Vibration attenuation of a continuous rotor-blisk-journal bearing system employing smooth nonlinear energy sinks. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 84, 128- 157 (2017)
29	ZANG, J., ZHANG, Y., DING, H., YANG, T. Z., and CHEN, L. Q. The evaluation of a nonlinear energy sink absorber based on the transmissibility. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 125, 99- 122 (2019)
30	ZHANG, Y., ZHANG, H., HOU, S., XU, K., and CHEN, L. Q. Vibration suppression of composite laminated plate with nonlinear energy sink. Acta Astronautica, 123, 109- 115 (2016)
31	PACHECO, D. R. Q., MARQUES, F. D., and FERREIRA, A. J. M. Panel flutter suppression with nonlinear energy sinks: numerical modeling and analysis. International Journal of NonLinear Mechanics, 106, 108- 114 (2018)
32	ZHANG, Y., SU, C., NI, Z., ZANG, J., and CHEN, L. Q. A multifunctional lattice sandwich structure with energy harvesting and nonlinear vibration control. Composite Structures, 221, 110875 (2019)
33	KRUSHYNSKA, A., TORRENT, D., ARAGÓN, A. M., ARDITO, R., and BILAL, O. R. Emerg-ing topics in nanophononics and elastic, acoustic, and mechanical metamaterials: an overview. Nanophotonics, 12 (4), 659- 686 (2023)
34	FANG, X., WEN, J., CHENG, L., YU, D., ZHANG, H., and GUMBSCH, P. Programmable gear-based mechanical metamaterials. Nature Materials, 21 (8), 869- 876 (2022)
35	SIROTA, L., SABSOVICH, D., LAHINI, Y., ILAN, R., and SHOKEF, Y. Real-time steering of curved sound beams in a feedback-based topological acoustic metamaterial. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 153, 107479 (2021)
36	LEE, S. H., PARK, C. M., SEO, Y. M., WANG, Z. G., and KIM, C. K. Composite acoustic medium with simultaneously negative density and modulus. Physical Review Letters, 104 (5), 54301 (2010)
37	LIU, Z., ZHANG, X., MAO, Y., ZHU, Y. Y., YANG, Z., CHAN, C. T., and SHENG, P. Locally resonant sonic materials. Science, 289 (5485), 1734- 1736 (2000)
38	LI, H., HU, Y., HUANG, H., CHEN, J., ZHAO, M., and LI, B. Broadband low-frequency vibration attenuation in 3D printed composite meta-lattice sandwich structures. Composites Part B: Engineering, 215, 108772 (2021)
39	BOSIA, F., POGGETTO, V. F., GLIOZZI, A. S., GRECO, G., LOTT, M., MINIACI, M., ONGARO, F., and ONORATO, M. Optimized structures for vibration attenuation and sound control in nature: a review. Matter, 5 (10), 3311- 3340 (2022)
40	CHEN, D., ZI, H., LI, Y., and LI, X. Low frequency ship vibration isolation using the band gap concept of sandwich plate-type elastic metastructures. Ocean Engineering, 235, 109460 (2021)
41	DENG, J., GUASCH, O., MAXIT, L., and GAO, N. Sound radiation and non-negative intensity of a metaplate consisting of an acoustic black hole plus local resonators. Composite Structures, 304, 116423 (2023)
42	BASTA, E., GHOMMEM, M., and EMAM, S. Flutter control and mitigation of limit cycle oscillations in aircraft wings using distributed vibration absorbers. Nonlinear Dynamics, 106 (3), 1975- 2003 (2021)
43	MICHELIS, T., PUTRANTO, A. B., and KOTSONIS, M. Attenuation of Tollmien-Schlichting waves using resonating surface-embedded phononic crystals. Physics of Fluids, 35 (4), 44101 (2023)
44	LIU, Y., DUAN, J., GAO, Y., and XU, B. Nonlinear supersonic aerothermoelastic analysis of asymmetrically curved-flber composite panels with nonuniform temperature distributions. Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology, 37 (3), 1325- 1337 (2023)
45	TIAN, W., ZHAO, T., and YANG, Z. Theoretical modelling and design of metamaterial stifiened plate for vibration suppression and supersonic flutter. Composite Structures, 282, 115010 (2022)
46	HE, Z. C., XIAO, X., and LI, E. Design for structural vibration suppression in laminate acoustic metamaterials. Composites Part B: Engineering, 131, 237- 252 (2017)
47	SHENG, P., FANG, X., WEN, J., and YU, D. Vibration properties and optimized design of a nonlinear acoustic metamaterial beam. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 492, 115739 (2021)
48	DUAN, Z. L., CUI, J. G., CHEN, L. Q., and YANG, T. Z. Nonlinear mechanical roton. Journal of Applied Mechanics, 90 (3), 031010 (2023)
49	PATIL, G. U., and MATLACK, K. H. Review of exploiting nonlinearity in phononic materials to enable nonlinear wave responses. Acta Mechanica, 233 (1), 1- 46 (2022)
50	WANG, K., ZHOU, J., WANG, Q., OUYANG, H., and XU, D. Low-frequency band gaps in a metamaterial rod by negative-stifiness mechanisms: design and experimental validation. Applied Physics Letters, 114 (25), 251902 (2019)
51	BUKHARI, M., and BARRY, O. Spectro-spatial analyses of a nonlinear metamaterial with multiple nonlinear local resonators. Nonlinear Dynamics, 99 (2), 1539- 1560 (2020)
52	FANG, X., WEN, J., BONELLO, B., YIN, J., and YU, D. Ultra-low and ultra-broad-band nonlinear acoustic metamaterials. Nature Communications, 8 (1), 1288 (2017)
53	FANG, X., WEN, J., YU, D., and YIN, J. Bridging-coupling band gaps in nonlinear acoustic metamaterials. Physical Review Applied, 10 (5), 034032 (2018)
54	FANG, X., WEN, J., BENISTY, H., and YU, D. Ultrabroad acoustical limiting in nonlinear metamaterials due to adaptive-broadening band-gap efiect. Physical Review B, 101 (10), 104304 (2020)
55	FANG, X., SHENG, P., WEN, J., CHEN, W., and CHENG, L. A nonlinear metamaterial plate for suppressing vibration and sound radiation. International Journal of Mechanical Sciences, 228, 107473 (2022)
56	ZHAO, T., YANG, Z., and TIAN, W. Tunable nonlinear metastructure with periodic bi-linear oscillators for broadband vibration suppression. Thin-Walled Structures, 191, 110975 (2023)
57	TIAN, W., ZHAO, T., and YANG, Z. Supersonic meta-plate with tunable-stifiness nonlinear oscillators for nonlinear flutter suppression. International Journal of Mechanical Sciences, 229, 107533 (2022)
58	TIAN, W., ZHAO, T., GU, Y., and YANG, Z. Supersonic flutter control and optimization of metamaterial plate. Chinese Journal of Aeronautics, 34 (11), 15- 20 (2021)
59	WARBURTON, G. B. The vibration of rectangular plates. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, 168 (1), 371- 384 (1954)
60	SHENG, P., FANG, X., DAI, L., YU, D., and WEN, J. Synthetical vibration reduction of the nonlinear acoustic metamaterial honeycomb sandwich plate. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 185, 109774 (2023)

[1]	Donghai HAN, Qi JIA, Yuanyu GAO, Qiduo JIN, Xin FANG, Jihong WEN, Dianlong YU. Local resonance metamaterial-based integrated design for suppressing longitudinal and transverse waves in fluid-conveying pipes [J]. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 2024, 45(10): 1821-1840.
[2]	Jihou YANG, Weixing ZHANG, Xiaodong YANG. Integrated device for multiscale series vibration reduction and energy harvesting [J]. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 2023, 44(12): 2227-2242.
[3]	Weixing ZHANG, Wei ZHANG, Xiangying GUO. Vertical vibration control using nonlinear energy sink with inertial amplifier [J]. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 2023, 44(10): 1721-1738.
[4]	Dongxu DU, Jun YANG, Wei SUN, Hongwei MA, Kunpeng XU. The semi-analytical modeling and vibration reduction analysis of the cylindrical shell with piezoelectric shunt damping patches [J]. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 2023, 44(10): 1675-1700.
[5]	Xumin GUO, Chunliang XIAO, Hui MA, Hui LI, Xufang ZHANG, Bangchun WEN. Improved frequency modeling and solution for parallel liquid-filled pipes considering both fluid-structure interaction and structural coupling [J]. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 2022, 43(8): 1269-1288.
[6]	Heng SU, Yegao QU, Guoxu WANG, Zhike PENG. Investigation on two-phase flow-induced vibrations of a piping structure with an elbow [J]. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 2022, 43(11): 1657-1674.
[7]	Weijiao CHEN, Yiming CAO, Xumin GUO, Hui MA, Bangchun WEN, Bo WANG. Nonlinear vibration analysis of pipeline considering the effects of soft nonlinear clamp [J]. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 2022, 43(10): 1555-1568.
[8]	Meng YANG, Xingjiu LUO, Xiaoqiang ZHANG, Hu DING, Liqun CHEN. Enhancing suspension vibration reduction by diagonal inerter [J]. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 2022, 43(10): 1531-1542.
[9]	Yanqing WANG, Han WU, Fengliu YANG, Quan WANG. An efficient method for vibration and stability analysis of rectangular plates axially moving in fluid [J]. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 2021, 42(2): 291-308.
[10]	E. KHANJANI, A. HAJARIAN, A. KARGAR-ESTAHBANATY, N. ARBABI, A. TAHERI, M. BAGHANI. Design and fluid-structure interaction analysis for a microfluidic T-junction with chemo-responsive hydrogel valves [J]. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 2020, 41(6): 939-952.
[11]	Yingjie WANG, Qichang ZHANG, Wei WANG, Tianzhi YANG. In-plane dynamics of a fluid-conveying corrugated pipe supported at both ends [J]. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 2019, 40(8): 1119-1134.
[12]	Yimin WEI, Sha WEI, Qianlong ZHANG, Xinjian DONG, Zhike PENG, Wenming ZHANG. Targeted energy transfer of a parallel nonlinear energy sink [J]. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 2019, 40(5): 621-630.
[13]	Yanqing WANG, J. W. ZU. Analytical analysis for vibration of longitudinally moving plate submerged in infinite liquid domain [J]. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 2017, 38(5): 625-646.
[14]	Shiliang HU, Chuanjing LU, Yousheng HE. Fluid-structure interaction simulation of three-dimensional flexible hydrofoil in water tunnel [J]. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 2016, 37(1): 15-26.
[15]	Han CHENG;Xin-hua ZHANG;Li YU;Meng CHEN. Study of velocity effects on parachute inflation performance based on fluid-structure interaction method [J]. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 2014, 35(9): 1177-1188.