On Chien’s question to the Hu-Washizu three-field functional and variational principle

doi:10.1007/s10483-022-2838-5

Abstract

Abstract: There is an open question, namely Chien’s question, in construction of a generalized functional in elasticity, i.e., why the stress-strain relation can still be derived from the Hu-Washizu generalized variational principle while the Lagrangian multiplier method is applied in vain? This study shows that the generalized variational principle can only be understood and implemented correctly within the framework of thermodynamics. This investigation finds that as long as the functional has one of the combinations (A(εij)-σ_ijε_ij) or (B(σ_ij)-σ_ijε_ij), its corresponding variational principle will produce the stress-strain relation without the need to introduce extra constraints by the Lagrangian multiplier method. This research proves that the Hu-Washizu functional Π_HW(u_ij, ε_ij; σ_ij) is real three-field functional, and resolves the historic academic controversy on the issue of constructing a three-field functional.

Key words: variational principle, elasticity, Lagrangian multiplier, thermodynamics, entropy

2010 MSC Number:

Bohua SUN. On Chien’s question to the Hu-Washizu three-field functional and variational principle. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 2022, 43(4): 537-546.

TrendMD

References

[1] HELLINGER, E. Die allgemeinen Ansätze der Mechanik der Kontinua. Enzyklopädie der Mathematischen Wissenschaften, 4(30), 654-655(1914)
[2] REISSNER, E. On a variational theorem in elasticity. Journal of Mathematics and Physics, 29(4), 90-95(1950)
[3] DE VEUBEKE, F. B. M. Diffusion des inconnues hyperstatiques dans les voilures á longeron couplés. Bulletin du Service Technique de l’Aéronautique, 24, 1-56(1951)
[4] HU, H. C. On the variational princinples in the theory of elasticity and the plasticity (in Chinese). Acta Physica Sinica, 10(3), 259-290(1954)
[5] NAGHDI, P. M. On a variational theorem in elasticity and its application to shell theory. Journal of Applied Mechanics, 31, 647-653(1954)
[6] HU, H. C. On some variational methods on the theory of elasticity and the theory of plasticity. Scientia Sinica, 4(1), 33-54(1955)
[7] WASHIZU, K. On the variational principles of elasticity and plasticity. Technical Report 25-18, Aeroelastic and Structures Research Laboratory, MIT, Cambridge (1955)
[8] REISSNER, E. On a variational theorem for finite elastic deformations. Journal of Mathematics and Physics, 32, 129-153(1953)
[9] GURTIN, M. E. Variational principles for linear elastodynamics. Archive for Rational Mechanics and Analysis, 16, 234-250(1964)
[10] REISSNER, E. A note on variational principles in elasticity. International Journal of Solids Struction, 1(1), 93-95(1965)
[11] FRAEIJS DE VEUBEKE, B. M. Displacement and Equilibrium Models in Stress Analysis, Wiley, London, 145-197(1965)
[12] TONTI, E. Variational principles in elastostatics. Mechanica, 2, 201-208(1967)
[13] WASHIZU, K. Variational Methods in Elasticity and Plasticity, Pergamon Press, New York (1968)
[14] PIAN, T. H. H. and TONG, P. Basis of finite element methods for solid continua. International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 1, 3-28(1969)
[15] DE VEUBEKE, F. B. A new variational principle for finite elastic deformations. International Journal of Engineering Science, 10, 745-763(1972)
[16] NEMAT-NASSER, S. General variational principles in nonlinear and linear elasticity with applications. Mechanics Today, 1, 214-261(1973)
[17] FRAEIJS DE VEUBEKE, B. M. Variational principles and the patch test. International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 8, 783-801(1974)
[18] ODEN, J. T. and REDDY, J. N. On dual complementary variational principles in mathematical physics. International Journal of Engineering Science, 12, 1-29(1974)
[19] OGDEN, R. W. A note on variational theorems in non-linear elastostatics. Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society, 77, 609-615(1975)
[20] BUFFER, H. Generalized variational principles with relaxed continuity requirements for certain nonlinear problems with an application to nonlinear elasticity. Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 19, 235-255(1979)
[21] HU, H. C. Variational Principles in Elasticity and Their Application, Science Publisher, Beijing (1980)
[22] CHIEN, W. Z. Variational Principles and Finite Element Method (in Chinese), Science Press, Beijing (1980)
[23] ODEN, J. T. and REDDY, J. N. Variational Methods in Theoretical Mechanics, Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1982)
[24] CHIEN, W. Z. Method of higher-order Lagrange multiplier and generalized variational principles of elasticity with more general forms. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 4(2), 143-157(1983)
[25] SUN, B. H. Generalized Variaonal Principle in Elasticity, M. Sc. disseration, Xi’an Insitute of Highway, China (1983)
[26] REISSNER, E. Variational Principles in Elasticity: Handbook of Finite Element Methods, McGraw-Hill, London (1983)
[27] REISSNER, E. Formulation of variational theorems in geometrically nonlinear elasticity. Journal of Engineering Mechanics, 110, 1377-1390(1984)
[28] REISSNER, E. On mixed variational formulations in finite elasticity. Acta Mechanica, 56, 117-125 (1985)
[29] CHIEN, W. Z. Generalized Variational Princinples (in Chinese), Knowledge Publisher, Beijing (1985)
[30] REISSNER, E. Some aspects of the variational principles problem in elasticity. Computational Mechanics, 1, 3-9(1986)
[31] SUN, B. H. Generalized Variational Principle of Electromagnatic Continua (in Chinese), Peking University Press, 178-184(1991)
[32] FELIPPA, C. A. A survey of parametrized variational principles and applications to computational mechanics. Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 113, 109-139(1994)
[33] FELIPPA, C. A. On the original publication of the general canonical functional of linear elasticity. Journal of Applied Mechanics, 67(1), 217-219(2000)
[34] KURRER, K. E., THRIFT, P., and RAMM, E. The History of the Theory of Structures Searching for Equilibrium, Wilhelm Ernst & Sohn, Berlin (2018)
[35] TRUESDELL, C. and TOUPIN, R. The Classical Field Theories, Springer, Berlin (1960)
[36] TRUESDELL, C. and NOLL, W. The Non-Linear Field Theories of Mechanics (ed. ANTMAN, S. S.), Springer, Berlin (2004)